Page 1 of 1 1
Topic Options
#18736 - 12/25/01 02:29 PM What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
Anonymous
Unregistered



hey im gunna be bying a new car within these 2 weeks...which car do u think is better and why? pros and cons please....Thanks a lot for the advice
Top
Visit Sponsors! Help CSi !
#18737 - 12/25/01 02:39 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
BlueSi24 Offline
Member


Registered: 09/27/01
Posts: 781
Loc: simi Valley
I think I would rather have the IS300. My reasoning is that it is a Japanese car. Ther is a wide variety of aftermarket parts for that car. Also I like the styling much more. However, I do hate you for having the money to buy those cars.
_________________________
AIM: Sk8orry FS: Skunk2 Coilover $200

Top
#18738 - 12/25/01 02:52 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
beretta627 Offline
Post Master


Registered: 02/07/00
Posts: 2726
Loc: Newton, MA
330 i like the 330 looks/performance over the IS300 ...

if the IS300 = Altezza though, it would be a closer race. Too bad.

------------------
AIM: beretta627
ARE U NOT JDM STYLE? IF NOT PLEASE DIAL 1800- IM WAK AS HELL

[This message has been edited by beretta627 on December 25, 2001 @ ]

Top
#18739 - 12/25/01 02:54 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
rcurley55 Offline
Post Master Supreme


Registered: 01/02/01
Posts: 13943
Loc: San Francisco, CA, USA
The German for sure. It's fit and finish are amazing. The new 3.0L is ultra smooth with 225Hp. It also develops 90% of it's torque by 2000rpm. The DSC (Dynamic Stability Control) system is also second to none. I've spend a lot of time driving a 330Ci, and everything about the car - steering, brakes, transmission, ergonomics is perfect.

Plus altezza lights suck...even when they belong on the car. The whole tail-light craze that followed the release of the IS300 ruined it. It's too bad, but when I look at the Lexus it looks like just another riced out honda at first glance.

There is plenty of aftermarket for the Bavarian as well. Dinan, AC Schnitzer, Hamman, Rouge Engineering, Racing Dynamics, Hartage, and Bavarian Motorsports are just a few sources for aftermarket parts for the German.

There is just something about German Engineered cars...far superior in my opinion. There are both BMW and Japanese car diehards on this board, so be prepared for a lot of mixed responses.

_________________________
Life is too short not to be M-Powered!

Top
#18740 - 12/25/01 04:08 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
TuPaK Si Offline
Post Master Sr


Registered: 02/17/01
Posts: 5198
Loc: So Cal
BMW, no doubt. No need for an explination

------------------
AIM - TuPaK Si

Top
#18741 - 12/25/01 04:26 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
Bonga Offline
Jr Poster


Registered: 12/21/01
Posts: 137
Loc: Buena Park, CA,
i will get stick 325 with sport package, and use the rest of budget to get 18'hamman or breyton wheels. think this basic setup can satisfy me pretty well

------------------
EG 5spd

_________________________
EG 5spd

Top
#18742 - 12/25/01 04:32 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
bc Offline
Poster


Registered: 08/06/01
Posts: 234
Loc: Ft. Lauderdale, FL
The 330 is quite a machine. Two of my buddies have them, one has the coupe with a 18 inch Hammans and one has the four door. I would get the coupe if I had the choice but they are both sweet!

------------------
2000 Civic Si EBP

_________________________
2000 Civic Si EBP - Stolen 03/28/02 2002 RSX Type S NBP - Aquired 04/15/02

Top
#18743 - 12/25/01 05:46 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
tHa DoPeSt Si Offline
Jr Member


Registered: 06/16/00
Posts: 557
Loc: Alhambra 626
I was thinking about getting one of those two cars too. I think that the BMW is a better built car, not to say that Lexus doesnt make quaility cars, but BMW signature is performance, and as close as the IS300 is to the 3 Series, the 330 could out perform that IS300 any day.

------------------
i ShIfT gEaRz WiTh No FeAr---->00 Eb Si # is between 1 & 30,000

_________________________
i ShIfT gEaRz WiTh No FeAr---->03 MINI COOPER S- W/ Every Pckg.

Top
#18744 - 12/25/01 07:19 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
nickw252 Offline
Post Master Sr


Registered: 10/12/01
Posts: 6243
Loc: Toledo, OH
I would definantly go with the Bimmer, one of my previous cars was an older BMW with over 230,000 miles on it and it was a great car. I love the style of the new 330 and the performance too. Get the steel blue color (whatever its called). One of my friends has driven an IS300 and said it was an amazing car but I'm sure I would still stick with the BMW. Just drive them and see how you like it.

Too bad I couldnt find a good picture of the blue one I like.

------------------
"I have seen gross intolerance shown in support of tolerance."
-Samuel Taylor Cooleridge

"So many rpms. So little time." -Honda

_________________________
2000 4 door Accord

Top
#18745 - 12/25/01 10:20 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
StuckonSI Offline
Post Master Sr


Registered: 01/16/00
Posts: 3897
Loc: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
No doubt the 330.

------------------
00 VSM SiR

_________________________
05 WDP TL

Top
#18746 - 12/25/01 10:22 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
SIINSI Offline
Post Master Sr


Registered: 03/30/01
Posts: 4463
Loc: Port St. Lucie, FL
330 over the IS anyday and twice on Sunday.

Not even the same sport if you ask me.

The IS is an expensive Civic with ugly taillights

Miguel

------------------
[IMG]http://mjwireless.com/Shaq/shaq.jpg[/IMG]
13.471@102.59
BGM in the house?

_________________________
2002 Torch Red - Z06 12.0@118

Top
#18747 - 12/25/01 11:59 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
meth0d Offline
Post Master Sr


Registered: 05/27/00
Posts: 4138
Loc: Toronto, Cambodia
IS300, just because the 330 is probably due for a redesign soon (isnt it?)

------------------
2000 Prelude

Top
#18748 - 12/26/01 12:08 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
Maelfyn Offline
Jr Member


Registered: 10/04/01
Posts: 619
Loc: Ellicott City, Maryland
I'm a Toyota guy so of course I will say the IS300 It's actually the car I would own if I could afford it. Especially with the new 5 speed transmission. The 2JZ-GE is a sweet engine and the car looks sweet as hell.

Seriously, I haven't been able to find performance information on the 5 speed IS300. What do they do in the quarter? Also are the FR or FF? FR I hope

------------------

- Joe

_________________________
'00 Toyota Celica GT Best time: 14.78 @ 93.42 mph on street tires with a 2.23 60 foot

Top
#18749 - 12/26/01 12:10 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
Maelfyn Offline
Jr Member


Registered: 10/04/01
Posts: 619
Loc: Ellicott City, Maryland
Since it's a 2JZ-GE, wouldn't it be a lot of fun to mod too? I would think there are is a lot of aftermarket for this engine? Just curious..

------------------

- Joe

_________________________
'00 Toyota Celica GT Best time: 14.78 @ 93.42 mph on street tires with a 2.23 60 foot

Top
#18750 - 12/26/01 12:23 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
003SiR Offline
Jr Member


Registered: 05/19/01
Posts: 705
Loc: Markham
330, no questions about it. The engine is responsive and torquey, has a very nice exhaust growl. The car is solid like a tank, yet handles most corners very well. I'm not sure about the US, but in Canada you get free maintance for 3 years on every Bimmer.
Top
#18751 - 12/26/01 01:46 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
rcurley55 Offline
Post Master Supreme


Registered: 01/02/01
Posts: 13943
Loc: San Francisco, CA, USA
quote:
Originally posted by Bonga:
i will get stick 325 with sport package, and use the rest of budget to get 18'hamman or breyton wheels. think this basic setup can satisfy me pretty well



If you have the extra...get the 330. You will thank me later. I've driven every config of the E46, and it is night and day between the 325 and 330 (I've flogged plenty of dealer courtesy cars). Both are excellent, but the 330 is just the cherry on top!!

quote:
Originally posted by meth0d:
IS300, just because the 330 is probably due for a redesign soon (isnt it?)

The 3 also just under went a mild front end change for the 2002 model year and some different options are standard/available. Check the headlights and front facias on the 2001 and the 2002 in the dealers - some subtle and not so subtle changes. Bi-Xenons are now available - previously high-beams were halogen. For the sport package now you get Euro Clears all the way around, and optional 18" from the factory. All 330s also get standard H/K premium systems with CD in-dash (i don't know why they even offer tapes anymore).

That's the changes that I can remember off the top of my head. Remeber the E36 design lasted from 94-98 (99 for the coupes, 00 for M3 and drop top) That's about 5 years, so I wouldn't expect a total redesign for at least 3 more years. The lexus has been out just as long, but it will probably have a longer shelf life.

[This message has been edited by rcurley55 on December 26, 2001 @ ]

_________________________
Life is too short not to be M-Powered!

Top
#18752 - 12/26/01 02:06 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
1slow_bowl_of_rice Offline
Post Master Sr


Registered: 08/19/01
Posts: 3528
Loc: NJ
Save your money and get an ///M3

------------------
99 FBP Civic

_________________________

Top
#18753 - 12/26/01 07:46 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
IK632 Offline
Post Master


Registered: 04/16/01
Posts: 2637
Loc: Apex, NC
I like the Lexus and when I looked at it I though it was pretty nice. But I am about the BMW, granted the bimmer will be more money. The BMW also costs more to upkeep and all that. However, my 96 feels as solid as the day it was new. I don't know how the IS300 will be (most likely pretty solid since Toyota is so good at what they do). When it boils down to it in the end Toyota built the Altezza/IS300 to take away business from BMW's 3 series. Drive both cars then decide which you like better. But be sure to compare similar packages.

------------------
Nick
96 M3, Cosmos Black - pretty much stock (but it's shiny)
"If I wanted any crap from you, I'd sqeeze your head."

Top
#18754 - 12/26/01 08:53 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
JacskonSi Offline
Post Master Sr


Registered: 09/01/01
Posts: 5356
Loc: Murray, Utah, USA
quote:
Originally posted by dhillon65:
hey im gunna be bying a new car within these 2 weeks...which car do u think is better and why? pros and cons please....Thanks a lot for the advice

I would take the new IS300 with the 5 speed manual!

_________________________
"Money is the root of all problems"

RIP: Samara...see you Samara! -12/08/05-
RIP: Pepper...rat face! -05/30/06-
RIP: Precious, my pretty kitty! -03/02/13-

Top
#18755 - 12/26/01 10:02 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
Anonymous
Unregistered



330ci

------------------
Tell him Ray...........KMART sucks

Top
#18756 - 12/26/01 10:16 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
GoQkRaCeR Offline
Post Master Sr


Registered: 01/24/00
Posts: 5079
Loc: Mn
yep
quote:
Originally posted by CivicHope:
330ci


------------------
Strictly Performance
Team Airborn
1998 ex
MY CAR IS FORSALE
pictures
http://a3.cpimg.com/image/51/C0/1664593-7550-02000180-.jpg
http://a7.cpimg.com/image/55/C0/1664597-7a2f-02000180-.jpg
http://a1.cpimg.com/image/4F/C0/1664591-7534-02000180-.jpg
http://a3.cpimg.com/image/ED/BD/1664493-5648-028001EE-.jpg
email me for info.

_________________________
-Triet Nguyen

Top
#18757 - 12/27/01 12:13 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
NR_si Offline
Post Master Sr


Registered: 12/20/99
Posts: 4212
Loc: RIT/Portland, ME
quote:
Originally posted by CivicHope:
330ci

Word, we don't like no stinking sedans.

------------------
2000 FBP Honda Civic Si
"The coast the hemisphere, look how hip-hop grew/
But it's still the proverbial sad clown of music/
Exploited by many, understood by few." - J-Live
"Life without knowledge is death in disguise." - Talib Kweli

_________________________
2000 FBP Honda Civic Si
The coast the hemisphere, look how hip-hop grew/
But it's still the proverbial sad clown of music/
Exploited by many, understood by few. - J-Live
Life without knowledge is death in disguise. - Talib Kweli

Top
#18758 - 12/27/01 12:22 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
IK632 Offline
Post Master


Registered: 04/16/01
Posts: 2637
Loc: Apex, NC
Once again, drive both and see what you like. From my experience most people I have seen on the road with IS300's have been dicks to me. But I can't generalize all IS300 owners. Some may be cool, but I have only met the less cool ones. On the other hand most of the M3 peeps I have met are pretty cool.

So I would still suggest giving the 330ci a good look. Only thing is you will be paying around 600/month for that car. That's provided you don't have a hefty down payment.

But, I almost went with this:

But then I found my M

------------------
Nick
96 M3, Cosmos Black - pretty much stock (but it's shiny)
"If I wanted any crap from you, I'd sqeeze your head."

Top
#18759 - 12/27/01 12:37 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
SYJ-MrQ Offline
Newbie


Registered: 05/27/01
Posts: 55
Loc: Dallas, TX
IS300 = boy's car
BMW 330ci = men's car

I'll pick 330ci anyday, unless your putting up against 540i, that's another day, another question. But if you that kind of money to send why not just add extra bucks and get new M3 with SMG II.

Top
#18760 - 12/26/01 02:33 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
BlueSi_425 Offline
Has No Pronouns on his Resume
Sr Member


Registered: 10/26/00
Posts: 1106
Loc: Auburn, WA, USA
What about a older M3?

------------------
" Ve go to European disco!.....Schnell!"

_________________________
Ve go to European disco!.....Schnell!

Top
#18761 - 12/26/01 04:40 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
SYJ-MrQ Offline
Newbie


Registered: 05/27/01
Posts: 55
Loc: Dallas, TX
Old M3??? puhahaha 330ci is the old M3. 330ci has the old M3 engine in it, but with better suspension and body style. Little heavier but hell rather have the new body style then the old ones.
Top
#18762 - 12/27/01 02:16 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
drunkenbabyseal Offline
Post Master Sr


Registered: 04/12/01
Posts: 4005
Loc: Reynoldsburg, OH
quote:
Originally posted by SYJ-MrQ:
Old M3??? puhahaha 330ci is the old M3. 330ci has the old M3 engine in it, but with better suspension and body style. Little heavier but hell rather have the new body style then the old ones.

not nearly. the old m3 could be the quickest practical car.

------------------
"the price is wrong bitch"
"who is your daddy and what does he do"
9/11/01

_________________________
I Love Afternoon Delight!

Top
#18763 - 12/27/01 03:57 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
rcurley55 Offline
Post Master Supreme


Registered: 01/02/01
Posts: 13943
Loc: San Francisco, CA, USA
quote:
Originally posted by SYJ-MrQ:
Old M3??? puhahaha 330ci is the old M3. 330ci has the old M3 engine in it, but with better suspension and body style. Little heavier but hell rather have the new body style then the old ones.

Sorry, but try again...when BMW redesigns cars, they go all out. That's why both the chassis and the engine have new codes. If you have ever driven the two cars, you know that they are totally different.

About the only thing the two engines really share is the crankshaft. The E36 M3 has the M50 powerplant, while the E46 330 has the M54 (this engine can also be found in the X5, Z3, and 5 series).

The E36 M3 made 240 hp and 225 lbft of torque (in US spec trim), while the 330 comes in around 225Hp and 215lbft of torque.

The E36 M3 used the single VANOS intake system while the E46 uses the double VANOS intake (Continuously variable length intake runners for more power/economy).

The E46 also features a totally electronic throttle butterfly and a refined drive-by-wire system

You would be hard pressed to find someone would would say that the 330 has a better suspension than the M3, but that is comparing apples to oranges. The E36 M3 has been touted as one of the best handling cars on the planet. They use different suspension geometry. The M3 is also tuned more aggressively than the 330 (even with the sport package). The non-sport package 330 is almost soft (nice comfort for the old folks though).

The older M3 has about a 200lb weight advantage on the E46. This translates into a 0-60 of about 5.7 in the old car and the 2001 running a mid to low 6 second time with a stick.


[This message has been edited by rcurley55 on December 27, 2001 @ ]

_________________________
Life is too short not to be M-Powered!

Top
#18764 - 12/27/01 04:00 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
rcurley55 Offline
Post Master Supreme


Registered: 01/02/01
Posts: 13943
Loc: San Francisco, CA, USA
sorry...double post

[This message has been edited by rcurley55 on December 27, 2001 @ ]

_________________________
Life is too short not to be M-Powered!

Top
#18765 - 12/27/01 08:04 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
IK632 Offline
Post Master


Registered: 04/16/01
Posts: 2637
Loc: Apex, NC
Nice explanation (dual vanos is variable cam timing on both cams). Single vanos advances the cam 12 degrees off idle and backs off at around 5000 rpm. I think you are talking about the E46M3 engine

quote:
Originally posted by rcurley55:
The E36 M3 used the single VANOS intake system while the E46 uses the double VANOS intake (Continuously variable length intake runners for more power/economy).

[This message has been edited by rcurley55 on December 27, 2001 @ ]


------------------
Nick
96 M3, Cosmos Black - pretty much stock (but it's shiny)
"If I wanted any crap from you, I'd sqeeze your head."

Top
#18766 - 12/27/01 08:08 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
IK632 Offline
Post Master


Registered: 04/16/01
Posts: 2637
Loc: Apex, NC
quote:
Originally posted by SYJ-MrQ:
Old M3??? puhahaha 330ci is the old M3. 330ci has the old M3 engine in it, but with better suspension and body style. Little heavier but hell rather have the new body style then the old ones.

The 96-99 E36M3 has the 3.2L single vanos motor. The E46 330ci has the 3.0 liter double vanos motor. They are totally different cars and the E36 M3 shouldn't be compared to the 330ci (they are too different). Now, the new M3 kicks some serious ass. Though the E36s over seas were getting that motor for the past 5 years. Now we finally get it. It's a shame we don't get launch control on the SMG here.

I suggest you drive the 2 before you go and compare apples to oranges again.

------------------
Nick
96 M3, Cosmos Black - pretty much stock (but it's shiny)
"If I wanted any crap from you, I'd sqeeze your head."

Top
#18767 - 12/28/01 12:57 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
rcurley55 Offline
Post Master Supreme


Registered: 01/02/01
Posts: 13943
Loc: San Francisco, CA, USA
quote:
Originally posted by IK632:
Nice explanation (dual vanos is variable cam timing on both cams). Single vanos advances the cam 12 degrees off idle and backs off at around 5000 rpm. I think you are talking about the E46M3 engine


Sorry, I was reading my Roundel last night about the new 7 series. That car (which is about as advanced as a space shuttle) has the continuously variable intake runners.

The E46 M3 has individual throttle bodies per each cylinder. The 330's double VANOS system varies both intake and exhaust timing, etc.

Oppps...it was late last night.

_________________________
Life is too short not to be M-Powered!

Top
#18768 - 12/28/01 12:59 AM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
rcurley55 Offline
Post Master Supreme


Registered: 01/02/01
Posts: 13943
Loc: San Francisco, CA, USA
quote:
Originally posted by IK632:
Nice explanation (dual vanos is variable cam timing on both cams). Single vanos advances the cam 12 degrees off idle and backs off at around 5000 rpm. I think you are talking about the E46M3 engine


Sorry, I was reading my Roundel last night about the new 7 series. That car (which is about as advanced as a space shuttle) has the continuously variable intake runners.

The E46 M3 has individual throttle bodies per each cylinder. The 330's double VANOS system varies both intake and exhaust timing, etc.

Oppps...it was late last night. Regardless, the cars coming out of Bavaria are simply amazing. Every car they build continues to gain accolades. If you get a 2001 330, make sure you have the factory retrofit for the steering. It will totally change the feel of the car.

_________________________
Life is too short not to be M-Powered!

Top
#18769 - 12/27/01 02:46 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
IK632 Offline
Post Master


Registered: 04/16/01
Posts: 2637
Loc: Apex, NC
quote:
Originally posted by rcurley55:
Sorry, I was reading my Roundel last night about the new 7 series. That car (which is about as advanced as a space shuttle) has the continuously variable intake runners.

The E46 M3 has individual throttle bodies per each cylinder. The 330's double VANOS system varies both intake and exhaust timing, etc.

Oppps...it was late last night. Regardless, the cars coming out of Bavaria are simply amazing. Every car they build continues to gain accolades. If you get a 2001 330, make sure you have the factory retrofit for the steering. It will totally change the feel of the car.



No problem. That 7 series is amazing. It's even got infinately variable lift to go with the timing. So it uses that instead of the butterflies. Sweet.


------------------
Nick
96 M3, Cosmos Black - pretty much stock (but it's shiny)
"If I wanted any crap from you, I'd sqeeze your head."

[This message has been edited by IK632 on December 27, 2001 @ ]

Top
#18770 - 12/27/01 08:14 PM Re: What would u rather buy? an is300 or a 330I?
Heedunk Offline
Post Master Sr


Registered: 05/07/00
Posts: 4926
Loc: California, USA
quote:
Originally posted by meth0d:
IS300, just because the 330 is probably due for a redesign soon (isnt it?)




ummm the 330 just came out this last year.

------------------
-=Heedunk=-
Trung H.
'99 EBP Civic Si
trung@sonnet.com

Top
Page 1 of 1 1


Moderator:  SiAdam, The Mad Paki 
Hop to:
Shout Box

CSi Sponsors
Civic Type-R 2-Piece Rotors — $814 Front Pair! Made in England!
View EBC Rotors
ClubSi.com Shirts
StopTech NZ
StopTech New Zealand
StopTech Australia
StopTech Australia
Brake Specials
Contact BuyBrakes
Brake Pad Coupon
Use Code: hondafetish
Advertisement

| Brake Pads | | How To Change Brake Pads | | Drilled Slotted Brake Kits Cheap | EBC Brake Kits | Performance Brake Kits | Brake Specials Near Me | How To Replace Brake Pads